What To Watch If You Love 'The Sinner'

Updated September 26, 2024 35 items

Ranked By

181voters561votes

Voting Rules

Vote up the films and television series that you know other fans of 'The Sinner' will love.

The Sinner kept viewers on the edge of their seats with its twists and turns, so it's no surprise that you’d be on the hunt for similar shows to watch after bingeing the entire series. Well, search no more, because this list has some of the best recommendations for movies and TV shows similar to The Sinner.

Deciding what to watch after The Sinner really depends on your mood, but if you’re looking for more crime dramas, Sharp Objects is a mystery thriller that you’ll almost certainly love if you like The Sinner.

Some other movies and TV shows like The Sinner in this list are movies like Zodiac, which centers on detectives trying to solve murders. Mindhunter is another good TV series that focuses on serial killers. Other good TV and movies recommended for The Sinner fans include The Killing, American Crime Story, and Gone Baby Gone.

With more than 40 million people visiting Ranker every month, we are able to offer you data-driven recommendations based on voting across thousands of film & TV polls.

- Photo:
  Broadchurch
  ITV
1
Broadchurch
Fans of investigative crime dramas, like The Sinner, will love this British serial featuring a star-studded cast of some of the island's greatest actors.

A community in Dorset, England, becomes the focus of a grisly murder investigation.
- Also ranks #1 on The Best Shows On The PBS Video App
- Also ranks #1 on These Gritty British Crime Dramas Make American Procedurals Look Tame
60 votes
Is this a good next watch?
What To Watch If You Love 'Broadchurch'
See all
1The Killing

97 Votes
2Happy Valley

81 Votes
3Hinterland

52 Votes
4River

16 Votes
- Photo:
  Paramount Pictures
2
Zodiac
This dark mystery film from the director of Fight Club and Gone Girl is the perfect choice when you want your fictional detectives just a little bit on the obsessive side.

Zodiac, an intriguing crime thriller directed by David Fincher, trails the chilling path of the famed Zodiac Killer. Robert Graysmith (Jake Gyllenhaal), a cartoonist at the San Francisco Chronicle, becomes obsessively intertwined with the unsolved case. Alongside him are Paul Avery (Robert Downey Jr.), a bohemian crime reporter, and Inspector David Toschi (Mark Ruffalo), a seasoned detective. As they delve deeper into the cipher-laden letters sent by the killer, their lives become inextricably linked to this enigma. The film, based on true events, is a tense exploration of obsession, fear, and the elusive nature of truth. Despite its long runtime, each moment is filled with suspense and intrigue, keeping viewers riveted until the very end. Zodiac remains a compelling testament to Fincher's mastery of his craft.
46 votes
Is this a good next watch?
- Photo:
  True Detective
3
True Detective
This anthology investagative drama series from HBO is the a great choice to dive into after finishing The Sinner if you're craving something in a similar vein.

Police investigations unearth the personal and professional secrets of those involved.
- Dig Deeper All Seasons Of 'True Detective,' Ranked
- Also ranks #5 on The Best Of Premium Cable TV Series
56 votes
Is this a good next watch?
The 30 Best Shows Like 'True Detective', Ranked By Fans
See all
1Mindhunter

135 Votes
2The Sopranos

65 Votes
3Fargo

56 Votes
4The Wire

70 Votes
- Photo:
  Fargo
4
Fargo
A new case and characters are followed each season in this anthology series set in the Midwest.
- Dig Deeper All of the Clever Easter Eggs Hiding in Fargo the TV Series
- Also ranks #1 on TV Shows That Feel A Little Like Watching A Tarantino Movie
18 votes
Is this a good next watch?
The 25 Best Shows Like 'Fargo', Ranked By Fans
See all
1Breaking Bad

57 Votes
2The Sopranos

31 Votes
3Game of Thrones

18 Votes
4Better Call Saul

46 Votes
- Photo:
  Sherlock
5
Sherlock
A contemporary spin on the novels by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, featuring the peerless Sherlock Holmes.
- Dig Deeper The Best Episodes Of 'Sherlock'
- Also ranks #1 on 285+ Smart TV Shows That Only Intellectuals Appreciate
14 votes
Is this a good next watch?
What to Watch If You Love 'Sherlock'
See all
1House

381 Votes
2Sherlock Holmes

252 Votes
3Sherlock Holmes

148 Votes
4Agatha Christie's Poirot

186 Votes
- Photo:
  The Killing
  AMC
6
The Killing
This series is the perfect choice if you want to continue down your rabbit hole of investigative crime dramas after finishing The Sinner.

Three distinct stories revolve around a single murder.
28 votes
Is this a good next watch?

Broadchurch

What To Watch If You Love 'Broadchurch'

Zodiac

True Detective

The 30 Best Shows Like 'True Detective', Ranked By Fans

Fargo

The 25 Best Shows Like 'Fargo', Ranked By Fans

Sherlock

What to Watch If You Love 'Sherlock'

The Killing