The Worst Winners in The Bachelorette History

Ranker TV
Updated August 1, 2025 21 items
Ranked By
819voters4.2Kvotes

Everyone was so happy when The Bachelorette was created. Finally they turned the tables and gave the ladies a chance to pass out those roses. And just like The Bachelor, The Bachelorette has given us ample opportunity to hate on the contestants. That's exactly why we've put together this list of the worst winners in The Bachelorette history.

Which winning dudes did you think were total duds? There have been some pretty terrible contestants on The Bachelorette over the years. From absolute cheese-balls, to down-right jerks, we've seen it all. Somehow these guys are even cattier than the contestants on The Bachelor! And yet, it seems like the worse they are, the farther they make it. 

Season after season, the contestants get more and more awful. Which is why we know you''ll love ranking our list of the worst guys who won Bachelorette. Check out this list of the worst Bachelorette winners and vote up the guy who should have to give all of his roses back. 

Most divisive: Jordan Rodgers
Over 800 Ranker voters have come together to rank this list of The Worst Winners in Bach History
This list is dynamically ranked based on user voting. The order reflects the consensus of our voters and is not influenced by paid placements or editorial bias.
Ranked by
  • Josh Murray
    1
    284 votes

    Josh Murray

  • Jef Holm
    2
    240 votes
  • Tino Franco
    3
    6 votes

    Tino Franco

  • Jordan Rodgers
    4
    283 votes

    Jordan Rodgers

  • Jed Wyatt
    5
    9 votes

    Jed Wyatt

  • Shawn Booth
    6
    249 votes

    Shawn Booth